Saturday-Monday, 10-12 July, 2004
Saturday-Monday, 10-12 July, 2004
Old order reasserts
'Parades Commission defunct' - Kelly
By Republican News
A legally binding determination by the Parades Commission was ignored this evening and and over a thousand loyalists were allowed to march provocatively through the Ardoyne in north Belfast, infuriating the area's nationalist residents.
Violent clashes resulted between Ardoyne residents and the North's security forces who had barricaded the community behind giant metal shutters for most of the day.
Angry and frustrated nationalists ignored efforts by Sinn Fein stewards to intervene and engaged in hand-to-hand fighting with riot PSNI police and British troops.
And following warnings by the SDLP earlier today, it appears that the party's support for the PSNI could now be withdrawn.
The loyalist supporters of the Protestant Orange Order had been barred by the Parades Commission from marching the return route from their main rally in Belfast back through Ardoyne. The march was part of wider Protestant celebrations of a 17th century battle victory over Catholics.
It followed a week of threats and intimidation, the unionist blockade of Ligoniel and last week's capitulation by the Parades Commission to similar threats over the parade in nearby Springfield Road.
However, as the day progressed, it was clear the Orange Order were being allowed to ignore the restrictions placed on them by the Parades Commission.
A mob of loyalists, who jeered and cheered as they strolled past the interface, threw missiles and attacked the residents later from side streets.
At one point, a number of British Army Land Rovers were caught in the middle of a large crowd, with only thick armour and reinforced glass protecting members of the Crown forces inside.
Later, a crowd of nationalists seized control of British Army batons and shields and attacked a small pocket of soldiers who were hemmed in around their Land Rover.
But in extraordinary scenes, Sinn Fein's Gerry Kelly acted frequently to protect members of the Crown forces.
However, even this intervention, and the efforts of the priests from the local Holy Cross Monastery, failed to stop the clashes.
Missiles were thrown, and a number of vehicles were attacked. Riot police fought back, kicking and baton-charging residents. Clashes were continuing tonight as the PSNI called in reinforcements and water-cannon.
Kelly called for calm as fighting continued.
He said: "The Parades Commission is now defunct because when it makes a decision the PSNI does whatever it wants to do anyway. They are cock-a-hoop because they are still in charge."
The North Belfast man said attacks on nationalists by the PSNI had made it difficult to prevent any retaliation. "People are not just physically hurt, they are mentally hurt. This is another slap in the teeth for nationalists."
Rumours that police would attempt to push through the supporters of the Orange Order were rife this afternoon.
Leading SDLP member Martin Morgan said that any failure by the PSNI to uphold the Parades Commission decision regarding the parade could see the party review its support for policing structures in the North.
Mr Morgan said his party expected a certain standard of policing in return for its participation in policing boards.
Sinn Fein President Gerry Adams MP also expressed his concern, which he said was "the worst case scenario".
However, the PSNI entirely capitulated to unionist threats by ignoring the determination of the Parades Commission and forced the march through.
Saturday-Monday, 10-12 July, 2004
Bonfire mayhem
By Republican News
The bonfires which mark the eve of the July 12th marches by the Protestant Orange Order is traditionally a focus for violence and this year was no exception.
In a night when nationalists generally stay indoors in fear of their lives, masked gunmen representing two rival gangs, the Ulster Defense Association and the Ulster Volunteer Force, fired handguns and sub-machineguns into the air.
"We are better prepared now than at any time in the past,'' one masked UDA man declared.
"It's still no surrender to the enemies of Ulster, no matter where they may be."
Many of the 'Eleventh Night' bonfires included Irish tricolour flags and Sinn Fein election posters in a mountain of combustible material.
There were a series of violent incidents across the North involving the bonfires, with most linked to local disputes among unionist paramilitaries and the consumption of alcohol.
In east Belfast, two men fired a number of shots into the air. According to reports, a car pulled up and the passenger tried to fire a handgun at a group of people. After the weapon jammed, the driver then fired a number of rounds into the air before driving off.
In west Belfast, a youth was seriously injured when he was stabbed at a bonfire.
There were also major disturbances involving clashes between loyalists and PSNI police in Randalstown, County Antrim and Limavady and Kilrea, both in County Derry.
This year saw some bonfires constructed and set ablaze on major roads and interchanges.
In North Belfast, two bonfires were constructed on the Crumlin Road, prompting a complaint from Sinn Fein.
"We already know that the twelfth bonfires cause serious air pollution. It is not good enough that they are also allowed to destroy the local infrastructure," said local councillor Eoin O'Broin.
Saturday-Monday, 10-12 July, 2004
Families attacked
By Republican News
A family including three children aged under five escaped injury in a petrol bomb attack on their County Derry home.
The incident brought back memories of the deaths of the three Quinn children on July 12, 1998 during a wave of violence related to the marching season.
A device was thrown at the rear of the family's house at Greenvale Park in Magherafelt shortly after 4.15am on Saturday.
A kitchen window and blinds were set on fire during the attack, when the petrol bomb was thrown from a lane at the back of the property.
The alarms was raised only when the mother of the children -- a five-year-old girl, a two-year-old boy and eight-week-old girl -- heard the noise of breaking glass.
The PSNI police confirmed the attack was "potentially life-threatening for the family".
The home of a Catholic family in Newry was also attacked. Paint was thrown at the house and car in a mixed estate on the outskirts of the city in the early hours of Saturday.
A glass jar with red paint was thrown at a window at the side of the house and vandals also spray-painted the car.
Sinn Fein councillor Mick Murphy urged unionist representatives in the area to condemn the attack.
"It is essential that unionist leaders support the removal of provocative flags from this mixed estate in the best interests of community relations," he added.
Saturday-Monday, 10-12 July, 2004
BBC criticised for promoting 'Twelfth'
By Republican News
Sinn Fein has criticised the coverage of the Twelfth marches by the Orange Order by the BBC.
West Tyrone assembly member Barry McElduff called on the broadcaster to review its coverage, pointing out that it promoted an anti-Catholic ethos.
The BBC today broadcast its traditional live coverage of the Orange Order's main demonstration in Belfast, and was to air a 40-minute programme of "highlights" tonight.
However, Mr McElduff claimed the programmes were a "sanitised and insulting spectacle".
"The colour parties containing the logos and flags of the Catholic killer gangs are ignored, the anti-Catholic ethos of the Orange Order is passed over and the supremacist nature of the marching season as a whole isn't mentioned," he said.
"The BBC need to realise that they no longer live in the days when nationalists will accept second class citizenship. They will not accept public money being used by the BBC to promote unionism and promote an anti-Catholic organisation like the Orange Order."
Saturday-Monday, 10-12 July, 2004
Feature: Orange Order - an alternative guide
By Republican News
The following account of the Orange Order and its early years is taken from 'For God and Ulster -- An Alternative Guide to the Loyal Orders' by the Pat Finucane Centre. See also our German translation Für Gott und Ulster
Each year on the Twelfth the media devote extensive coverage to a series of parades which take place throughout the North of Ireland. Mention is made of the carnival atmosphere, the spectators along the route, family groups picnicking on the grass at the end of a long day and the sheer colour of it all. The majority of the parades are organised by the Orange Order, a benign religious and cultural organisation according to its supporters. A sectarian and deeply political organisation according to its detractors. But what is the Orange Order? Membership is restricted to male Protestants who must fulfill the following:
Qualifications of an Orangeman
"An Orangeman should have a sincere love and veneration for his Heavenly Father; a humble and steadfast faith in Jesus Christ, the Saviour of mankind, believing in Him as the only Mediator between God and man. He should cultivate truth and justice, brotherly kindness and charity, devotion and piety, concord and unity, and obedience to the laws; his deportment should be gentle and compassionate, kind and courteous; he should seek a society of the virtuous, and avoid that of the evil; he should honour and diligently study the Holy Scriptures, and make them the rule of his faith and practice; he should love, uphold, and defend the Protestant religion, and sincerely desire and endeavour to propagate its doctrines and precepts; he should strenuously oppose the fatal errors and doctrines of the Church of Rome, and scrupulously avoid countenancing (by his presence or otherwise) any act of ceremony of Popish worship; he should by all lawful means, resist the ascendancy of that Church, its encroachments, and the extension of its power, ever abstaining from all uncharitable words, actions or sentiments, towards his Roman Catholic brethren; he should remember to keep holy the Sabbath day, and attend the public worship of God, and diligently train up his offspring, and all under his control, in the fear of God, and in the Protestant faith; he should never take the name of God in vain, but abstain from all cursing and profane language, and use every opportunity of discouraging these, and all other sinful practices, in others; his conduct should be guided by wisdom and prudence, and marked by honesty, temperance, and sobriety; the glory of God and the welfare of man, the honour of his Sovereign, and the good of his country, should be the motive of his actions."
Candidates must be proposed by a member of a lodge (under law 84) and promise among other things to:
at all times conform to the Laws and Ordinances of the Loyal Orange Institution of Ireland, and will at all times recognise and support the authority of the Grand Orange Lodge of Ireland.
I promise that, if admitted a member of this Lodge, I will always show due respect to the Worshipful Master and other Officers, and will endeavour to conduct myself as a Brother ought towards all members of the Lodge and of the Brotherhood, and that I will always observe and never knowingly violate, the By-Laws of the Lodge.
I was born at ................... in the county of ...................... of Protestant parents, was educated in the Protestant faith, and have never been in any way connected with the Church of Rome. My wife is a Protestant/I am unmarried..
PARADES - THE FIRST HUNDRED YEARS
1796 First Twelfth parades held at a number of venues including Lurgan, Portadown and Waringstown. The Northern Star reports that a Mr M'Murdie, an Orangeman, died of stab wounds following clashes with the militia in Aghalee (Jarman,1997, p.47).
Seven months earlier, the Governor of Armagh, Lord Gosford, spoke to a meeting of magistrates about the activities of the newly formed Orange Order:
"It is no secret that a persecution is now raging in this country ... the only crime is ... profession of the Roman Catholic faith. A lawless banditti have constituted themselves judges ..." (Curtis, 1995, p.9).
1797 14 people are killed in violence during an Orange parade in Stewartstown , Co. Tyrone.
1813 An Orange procession attempts to parade down Hercules Street (later Royal Avenue) in Belfast, then a narrow lane and the first 'identifiable Catholic neighbourhood' in the city. In the resultant violence four men die. The prosecutor in a subsequent trial notes that the Orange Order, "...had presumed to arrogate to themselves a title to exclusive loyalty ... [but] ... whatsoever be their professions, tend to disturb the public peace" (Hepburn, 1996, p.1).
1814 The Apprentice Boys of Derry Club, precursor of the present organisation, is founded.
1818 A number of people are injured during disturbances at an Orange parade in Kilrea, Co Derry. In Liverpool Orangemen attempt to burn effigies of the Pope and the Cardinal outside the Catholic Cathedral but are stopped by the Mayor (Gray, 1972, p.93).
1822 Fighting breaks out following an Orange parade in Middletown, Co Armagh. One man, Patrick Grimley, is killed. In Derry the Apprentice Boys parade is attacked. Tension in the city is linked to Catholic frustration at their continued exclusion from local political power and the growing campaign for Catholic Emancipation.
1823 The British Government puts restrictions on 'popular societies' (including the Catholic Association) curbing the Orange Order and its parades. It becomes illegal for the Order to administer oaths. As a consequence the Order is dissolved and reconstituted. Trouble is reported at the Twelfth parade in Killyleagh, Co Down.
1824 Serious disturbances occur at Twelfth parades in Belfast, Donaghadee, Downpatrick, Dromore and Newry.
1825 Sectarian confrontations follow Orange parades in Belfast. The Grand Lodge of the Orange Order dissolves itself in response to the Unlawful Societies Act. Nevertheless in Portadown and elsewhere Orangemen defy the law and continue to parade.
1827 Portadown Orangemen again defy the law and some 5000 march in the town.
1828 The Duke of Cumberland, Imperial Grand Master, in a letter to the Earl of Enniskillen, Deputy Grand Master, warns of the danger that "our public processions" could lead to "... a breach of the public peace ..." which could result in a ban on processions (Gray, 1972, p.112). The Belfast parades are canceled but illegal processions take place in several areas.
1829 The Grand Master tries unsuccessfully to cancel that year's parades but he is ignored. Trouble occurs in Armagh, Bellaghy, Comber, Greyabbey, Glenoe, Portadown and Strabane where 3 people are seriously injured. In Stewartstown one man dies while seven are killed in disturbances in Clones and eight are killed in Enniskillen. In Maghera, Co Derry, several Catholic homes were burnt down prompting the intervention of the military who arrest a number of Orangemen. At their court appearance the men are rescued by a large mob. The magistrate instructs the police not to intervene (Gray, 1972, p.114).
1830 The Lord Lieutenant bans all processions but this is again ignored. In Maghery, Co Armagh "fierce fighting" breaks out between Orangemen and Catholic villagers "despite the presence of a large force of police and military" (Murphy, 1981, p.69 and Gray, 1972, p.114). Throughout the 1830s and 1840s clashes occur on the Twelfth in Belfast between the Catholic 'Pound boys' and the Protestant 'Sandy Row boys'. In Scotland regular clashes occur between Orangemen and Irish immigrants.
1832 Belfast Orangemen celebrate a Tory election victory with an attack on a Catholic area whereupon fierce and prolonged fighting" follows. Four people die. The Northern Whig describes a prominent Orangeman, a Mr Boyce, addressing his followers from the window of the Tories' committee room where they were reassured that "the Protestants had gained this victory, and that they would continue to maintain their ascendancy" (Curtis, 1995, p.36). The Party Processions Act comes into force. Those attempting to parade are prosecuted.
1833 In Tandragee an effigy is burnt of a local magistrate who had served warrants on Orangemen and rioting ensues during the Orange parade (Campbell, 1991, p.152). Illegal parades by Portadown Orangemen continue and Ballyhagan, a Catholic area near Portadown, is besieged by Orangemen who attack a number of homes.
1835 A riot erupts on the Twelfth following a controversy over an Orange arch in the Sandy Row area of Belfast. Meanwhile Hugh Donnelly, a Catholic from Drumcree, is killed in a confrontation with Orangemen near Portadown. In evidence to a Parliamentary Select Committee set up to investigate the Orange Order an Armagh Magistrate, William Hancock, a Protestant, said:
"For some time past the peaceable inhabitants of the parish of Drumcree have been insulted and outraged by large bodies of Orangemen parading the highways, playing party tunes, firing shots, and using the most opprobrious epithets they could invent...a body of Orangemen marched through the town and proceeded to Drumcree church, passing by the Catholic chapel though it was a considerable distance out of their way."
1836 The military use six pieces of artillery (!) to help quell trouble at an Orange gathering at Scarva. In Derry party parades are banned (Murphy, 1981, p.56).
1845 Following the lifting of the Party Processions Act Orange parades again take place in many areas.
1846 Trouble flares at Orange parades in Armagh and Newry.
1848 Trouble flares between Orangemen and those taking part in St Patrick's Day parades in Downpatrick, Ballynahinch and Hilltown.
1849 St Patrick's Day parades are again a source of conflict between Orangemen and marchers in Castlewellan and Crossgar. An Orange demonstration is hosted by Lord Roden, Grand Master of the Orange Order, on his estate at Tullymore, near Castlewellan, County Down. Roden launches a fiery verbal attack on Catholicism. Catholics, seeking revenge for the St Patrick's Day incidents, attack Orangemen at nearby Dolly's Brae. Six (Stewart, 1997 a, p.135), eight (Jarman,1997, p.55) or thirty (Campbell, 1991, pp. 255 ) Catholics are reported killed in the subsequent clashes with Orangemen and the militia. The event passes into Orange folklore. An official commission of inquiry condemns Roden's role and he is forced to resign as justice of the peace but remains Grand Master.
1850 As a result of the clashes at Dolly's Brae the Party Processions Act is renewed forbidding public displays and demonstrations.
1857 Following serious disturbances in Belfast the commissioners of the Belfast Riot Inquiry rule that the "originating cause of the riots" were the July 12 orange parades (Darby,1986, p.11). The Inquiry went on to state that the "celebration of that festival" was used "to remind one party of the triumphs of their ancestors over those of the other, and to inculcate the feelings of Protestant superiority over their Roman Catholic neighbours"(Stewart, 1997 a, p.151).
1860 One man dies and 15 others are wounded when Orangemen open fire on Catholics in Derrymacash, between Lurgan and Portadown, during an Orange parade. The Party Processions Act was subsequently amended to prohibit the carrying of arms on parades but this had "little or no effect" where the judiciary, military and police "were either openly sympathetic to, or intimidated by, Orangeism" (GRRC, 1996, pp.14).
1866 In Portadown three Orangemen are arrested and charged with "meeting and parading in the public road, wearing party colours, and playing music, which was calculated to provoke animosity between different classes of Her Majesty's subjects"(Walker, 1996, p.93).
1867 William Johnson of Ballykilbeg, a legendary figure in Orangeism, challenges the ban on parades by leading a large group of Orangemen from Newtownards to Bangor in "a display of Orange strength against the growing menace of Fenianism" (Gray, 1972, p.152). As a result he is convicted and serves time in Downpatrick gaol. Johnson was a fascinating figure who went on to defend the rights of Catholics to march. By this stage a massive campaign of civil disobedience had made the ban unworkable. With the collapse of the Party Processions Act the British Administration in Ireland institute a policy of "equal marching rights". Parades are allowed to proceed but are restricted to non-contentious areas (Hepburn,1996, p.247 ). In west Ulster Orange parades are revived "in protest at the laxity of Dublin Castle in dealing with sympathy demonstrations for the Fenians." An attempted Orange procession at Muff Glen near Derry is blocked by heavily armed Catholics (Murphy, 1981, p.117).
1869 Following rioting in the city the Londonderry Riot Inquiry notes that "the character of the demonstrations (by the Apprentice Boys) has certainly undergone a change, and, among the Catholic lower classes at least, they are now regarded with the most hostile feelings" (Darby, 1986, p.11). The Inquiry recommended that Orange parades be banned since they represented "the proudest recollection of one section" and "bitter humiliation" for the other (ibid., p.15). The 'Shutting of the Gates' ceremony in December, organised by the Apprentice Boys , sparks a counter-demonstration of several thousand people.
1870 In Derry a campaign of opposition to Apprentice Boys parades continues. In August a nationalist counter-demonstration to the Apprentice Boys parade is banned and "serious rioting ensued". The controversy over parades continued. Lacy notes that in Derry: "from 1877 onwards the determination of Catholics to have the same rights as Protestants to march inside the walled city was increasingly asserted. The early 1880s were marked by many confrontations over marches and there was increased sectarian tension" (Lacy, 1990, p.203).
1883 Trouble flares in Donegal town when an Orange counter-demonstration was organised in opposition to Michael Davitt, one of the leaders of the Land League who was to address a meeting in the town. In Derry city "two persons receive wounds of a serious character" in clashes between Bogsiders and Apprentice Boys who have taken over the Town Hall in the Diamond during a visit to the city by the nationalist mayor of Dublin (Stewart, 1997, p.74).
1886 The Orange Order mobilises in opposition to Gladstone's Home Rule Bill with parades throughout the North. In a letter Randolf Churchill incites Orangemen and Unionists to violence with the call "Ulster will fight (Home Rule), Ulster will be right." Rioting follows the defeat of the Bill in June and 12 July Orange parades lead predictably to disturbances that are "probably the worst outbreak of violence that century". By mid September some 50 people had lost their lives and thousands had been driven from their workplaces and homes (Curtis, 1995, p.142 ).
The growing political role of the Orange Order in the 1880s in co-ordinating the anti-Home Rule campaign had important implications for that most public manifestation of Orangeism, i.e. the parade. The middle classes and the gentry flocked back to the Loyal Orders having deserted them in the early decades of the century as disreputable "lawless banditti". Institutional links with the emerging Ulster Unionist Party were developed and the Orders became more centralised and focused political machines. Mass mobilisations were co-ordinated in pursuit of a clear goal ; the defeat of Home Rule which the Orders claimed equaled "Rome Rule". Annual skirmishes on the highways and byways of Ulster, though they still occurred, were no longer seen as appropriate to an organisation which had regained its respectability.
Saturday-Monday, 10-12 July, 2004
Analysis: Orange culture
By Republican News - for the Andersonstown News
Looking forward to The Twalf? Probably not. It is interesting, though.
I mean, the way rich and lordly people manipulated what they called "the lower orders" to do their bidding. "The lower orders", of course, get nothing much out of it, except mythology. And bad pay. And poor housing. And inadequate education. And good suits. And a bad reputation.
If you look at the lists of people involved in leadership of the Orange Order in its early days, you find the names of various "landed gentry", earls, sirs, reverends and so forth. It was said to be a great bringer together of the "upper" and "lower" classes. It was not of course - it was a way of allowing the "upper" classes to control the rest.
But that day is passing. Look at the list of people who lead the Orange Order now, the number of "upper class" ones is getting smaller. The Order does not know where it is going or with whom. With the help of the Parades Commission it is going more places than it should, but that is not for ever.
Religious as it is, it still has the power to create riots in the streets and that is something the Parades Commission has to be wary of. The power of the Order was reduced when the anti-discrimination laws came out - weak as they are they did make some difference because it is more expensive now to refuse people jobs who are qualified for them. So if the Orange Order cannot get you a job, why join it? It was predicted that once the weak anti-discrimination laws began to have some effect the membership of the Order would grow less. And this seems to be happening.
Its main attraction will be for those who still want some means of asserting the extreme views of those who believe in the Chosen Race Theory, namely the belief that God has chosen certain people for his own and they are entitled to beat everybody else into the ground. Old Testament idea. Among other sources.
So a number of associations are on the decline - the Orange Order, Mr Paisley's church, the Ulster Unionist Party. People who value the union with Britain in spite of the economic decline it has brought on us, seem to be slipping away from all three. They are now placing their trust in Mr Paisley's political party which at present attracts the votes of most of the Protestant people. If that party, however, makes any moves towards living and working with other parties, these voters may think again and look for yet another party which will promise to ensure the eternal reign of London over Irish affairs. But it is doubtful if such a party can emerge from present day unionist politics. The UK Unionist Party is a disturbing example for them of what can happen when you try to create a party from behind a writing desk rather than encourage one to rise up from the people. One of the useful things our researchers could do is read the accounts of the Twelfth of July speeches as reported in the unionist papers of long ago. In the 1920s and '30s and later, these speeches were of considerable fierceness. And given by some very "respectable " people, clergymen included. Such a study would be a useful means of introducing a sense of reality into discussions about peace and reconciliation. The Twelfth speeches were so fierce that a reforming editor of the Tele in the 1970s, Jack Sayers, eventually published only extracts from them, the less appalling bits. It is also worth studying how, as the "upper classes" tended to slide away from the Order, what they called the "lower orders" began to take control.
In the 1920s it was taken for granted that the landed gentry (what labels they had for themselves!) would control everything. It was not nice for them when occasionally a member of the commercial classes like Brian Faulkner or John Andrews would become prime minister. For some this was dangerous.
Mr Andrews dealt in things, so did Mr Faulkner (one in meal, the other in shirts) and shudders must have run through many a drawing room at the thought that the commercial classes were getting above themselves. The landed gentry, however, were capable of producing neither the number nor the talents to run even the North of Ireland. The landed gentry and the "upper classes" had to rely more and more not on their own powers but on the support, money and even threats of the London administration.
It is indeed an interesting story. The churches began to be dominated by the Paisley people, unionist politics by the same, the Orange Order by the open-necked shirt people and business by, well, by, well, who owns the newspapers now?
You see our problem. The ousting of the landed gentry from Ulster politics is bad enough, its replacement by the commercial classes is worse, and good heavens, if the commercial classes turn out to be The Wrong People, where have we got to and where are we going?
Uncertainty and even demoralisation prevails.
No wonder so few people turned up at Drumcree church last weekend.